שפת אמת

Sincerity of heart outweighs quantity

Vayikra · תרל"ו (1875) · Essay 2

korbanos · kavanah · simcha · avodah · Adar

במשנה נאמר בבהמה ריח ניחוח ובעוף ריח ניחוח ובמנחה ריח ניחוח לומר לך אחד המרבה ואחד הממעיט ובלבד שיכוון לבו לשמים.

In the Mishnah it says: by an animal "a sweet savor," by a bird "a sweet savor," and by a meal-offering "a sweet savor" — to teach you that it is all the same whether one brings much or one brings little, provided that he directs his heart to Shomayim.

Whether a person brings a costly animal-offering or only an inexpensive meal-offering, the Torah uses the identical phrase "a sweet savor," teaching that what counts before Hashem is the sincerity of the heart, not the size of the gift.

בט"ז הקשה ממ"נ אי גם המרבה כוונתו לשמים אם כן המרבה עדיף ע"ש שמיישב בטוב טעם ודעת.

The Taz raised a difficulty: either way — if the one who brings much also has his intention directed to Shomayim, then the one who brings much should be preferable! See there how he resolves it with good reasoning and insight.

The Taz asks: if both have proper intention, the larger offering carries that intention plus more substance, so why are they called equal? He gives his own answer there.

אעפ"כ נראה דקושיא מעיקרא ליתא.

Even so, it appears that the question has no basis to begin with.

The Sefas Emes suggests that the difficulty itself dissolves once we understand what avodah truly is.

כי באמת אין הפרש בין מרבה לממעיט אף אם שניהם מתכוונים לטוב.

For in truth there is no difference between the one who brings much and the one who brings little, even if both intend for the good.

In serving Hashem, quantity does not register as a measure of worth at all.

כי בעבודת הבורא אין נ"מ בריבוי רק בהתעוררות רצון אמת בלב.

For in the avodah of the Creator there is no practical difference made by abundance — only by the awakening of a true ratzon (desire) in the heart.

What Hashem desires is the genuine stirring of the heart toward Him; the physical scale of the deed is irrelevant.

ואדרבא מי שאינו יכול לעשות הרבה ומכוון בהמעט אפשר חשוב יותר.

On the contrary, one who is unable to do much yet directs his heart with the little he brings — perhaps he is more esteemed.

A person whose means are small but whose heart is fully invested may stand higher before Hashem than the wealthy giver.

ובאמת נראה הפי' מרבה וממעיט בענין ימי הטובה וימי הרעה כי התרבות המעשים טובים בעת פתיחות לב האדם.

And in truth it appears that the meaning of "much" and "little" refers to the days of good and the days of hardship — for the multiplying of deeds belongs to a time when a person's heart is open.

The Sefas Emes re-reads "much" and "little" not as the size of the offering but as life's seasons: in expansive, joyful times a person naturally does more.

והתמעטות המעשים בימי הרעה שניהם בקנה אחד עולים.

And the diminishing of deeds in the days of hardship — the two of them rise as one.

Doing less during dark, constricted times is weighed equally with doing more during good times; both ascend together before Hashem.

והוא כענין שאמרו בשם הרב מלובלין הקדוש ז"ל לפרש הגמ' משנכנס אדר מרבין בשמחה ואב ממעטין בשמחה.

This is like what was said in the name of the holy Rav of Lublin, zal, to explain the Gemara: "When Adar enters we increase in joy, and in Av we decrease in joy."

He cites a teaching of the holy Chozeh of Lublin on the Gemara (Taanis 29a) about increasing simcha in Adar and decreasing it in Av.

ופי' להרבות צד הקדושה ולמעט צד הטומאה.

And he explained it to mean: to increase the side of holiness and to decrease the side of impurity.

"Increasing" and "decreasing" are two complementary forms of one avodah — building up kedushah and tearing down tumah.

וכן נפרש כאן.

And so we may explain here.

The same principle applies to "the one who brings much and the one who brings little."

וגם דברים אלו נכללין בדברי הט"ז ע"ש באו"ח סימן א':

And these matters too are included in the words of the Taz; see there in Orach Chaim, siman 1.

The Sefas Emes notes that his own resolution is in fact already hinted at within the Taz's discussion at the opening of the Shulchan Aruch.

Summary: What Hashem treasures in avodah is the true awakening of the heart, not the size of the offering. "Much" and "little" describe life's open and constricted seasons alike — increasing the good in times of light and minimizing the negative in times of darkness both rise together as "a sweet savor" before Hashem.

Sincerity of heart outweighs quantity — Vayikra תרל"ו — Sfas Emes Library