Every Jew is Hashem's witness
witness · Har Sinai · malchus · inner knowledge · teshuvah
בפסוק ונפש כי תחטא כו' והוא עד כו' במדרש מפרש על בנ"י שכל אחד מושבע מהר סיני וזה ושמעה קול אלה והוא עד כמ"ש אתם עדי.
On the pasuk "And a soul that sins … and he is a witness …" (Vayikra 5:1), the Midrash explains it concerning Bnei Yisrael — that each one was sworn at Har Sinai, and this is "and he heard the voice of an oath, and he is a witness," as it says, "You are My witnesses" (Yeshayahu 43:10).
The Midrash applies the law of the witness to all of Bnei Yisrael: at Sinai each Yid was placed under oath and made a "witness" to Hashem's kingship.
או ראה אתה הראת.
Or "he saw" — "You have been shown to know" (Devarim 4:35).
The "seeing" in the witness-law corresponds to the revelation at Sinai: "You have been shown, to know that Hashem is God."
או ידע וידעת היום כו'.
Or "he knew" — "And you shall know this day …" (Devarim 4:39).
The "knowing" of the witness corresponds to the implanted knowledge of Hashem's sovereignty: "Know this day."
פי' שבני ישראל נשלחו בעוה"ז לברר מלכותו ית' ויש לכל אחד מישראל השגה וידיעה בנקודת הלב להכיר כבוד מלכותו ית' וצריך למשוך הכל אחר זאת הידיעה.
The meaning is that Bnei Yisrael were sent into this world to clarify His kingship, and every Yid has perception and knowledge in the inner point of the heart to recognize the glory of His kingship, and one must draw everything after this knowledge.
Each Yid's mission (shlichus) in this world is to make Hashem's malchus (kingship) manifest; he carries an inner knowledge of it in the point of his heart and must pull his whole self along after that knowledge.
וזה אם לא יגיד הגדה לשון המשכה.
And this is "if he does not tell (yaggid)" — "haggadah" is a term of drawing forth.
The witness's obligation to "tell" (yaggid) is read as a term of hamshachah (drawing down/extending): the Yid must "draw out" and express the inner knowledge he bears.
כי תחטא יש לפרש ששליחת הנפש בעוה"ז הוא חסרון בגוף הנפש אך התיקון ע"י בירור כבודו ית' בעולם וז"ש הפסוק שזה תיקון הנפש בעולם.
"If a soul sins" can be explained: the sending of the soul into this world is itself a deficiency in the body of the soul, but the rectification comes through clarifying His glory in the world; and this is what the pasuk says — that this is the tikkun (rectification) of the soul in the world.
"Chet" can mean lack: the soul's very descent into a body is a kind of diminishment, and its tikkun is achieved by revealing Hashem's glory in the world — the soul's whole purpose here.
אך י"ל עוד שקאי אחר החטא ממש שאין צדיק בארץ כו'.
But one can also say that it refers to actual sin, since "there is no tzaddik on earth who does only good and never sins" (Koheles 7:20).
Alternatively the pasuk speaks of real sin, which no one entirely escapes.
ולמה כן.
And why is it so?
Why did Hashem arrange that even the righteous stumble?
שע"י החטא אם יתחזק לשוב להשי"ת יוכל לתקן יותר ולהמשיך כל המעשים אחר הבורא ית'.
Because through the sin, if he strengthens himself to return to Hashem, he can rectify even more and draw all his deeds after the Creator.
Sin opens the door to teshuvah; rising back to Hashem accomplishes an even greater tikkun, drawing all one's actions after the Creator.
וז"ש כי תחטא ואעפ"כ יש בו הידיעה כו' שהיא נפש הישראלי אם לא יגיד כו' שזה תיקון החטא כנ"ל:
And this is "if he sins" — and even so there remains within him the knowledge, which is the Jewish soul; "if he does not tell" — for this drawing-out is the rectification of the sin, as above.
Even after sin, the inner knowledge — the Jewish neshamah — endures; expressing and drawing it forth is precisely how the sin is mended.
Summary: The law of the reluctant witness is read as the mission of every Yid, sworn at Sinai to be a "witness" to Hashem's kingship. Each carries an inner knowledge of His glory in the point of the heart and must "draw it out" (haggadah as hamshachah). Whether "chet" means the soul's deficiency in descending to this world or actual sin, the tikkun is the same: revealing Hashem's glory and channeling all one's deeds after the Creator — and teshuvah after sin achieves an even greater rectification.