Milah Refines the Body to Receive Holiness
בפרשת מילה התהלך לפני והי' תמים איתא במדרש תנחומא התחיל תמה עכשיו אני חסר וכשאמול אהיה שלם ע"ש [וגם להבין רמז החכמים דיו לעבד להיות כרבו] כי בודאי מאחר שזו הערלה צריכין להסירו בודאי אין בו פנימיות.
In the parsha of milah: "Walk before Me and be tamim (whole)" (Bereishis 17:1). The Midrash Tanchuma says: Avraham began to wonder — "Now I am lacking, and when I circumcise myself I will be complete" — see there. [And also to understand the hint of the Chachamim, "it is enough for the servant to be like his master."] For surely, since this orlah (foreskin) must be removed, certainly it has no penimiyus (inner essence).
Avraham realizes that the body is not yet "whole" until the orlah is removed. The Sefas Emes infers that anything which must be cut away has no holy inner core — it is purely external covering.
כי הגוף הוא מלבוש הנפש והנשמה.
For the body is the garment of the nefesh and the neshamah.
The physical body is merely a "garment" clothing the soul; its purpose is to serve the inner spiritual life.
ורק שצריך להיות הגוף מתוקן שיוכל לקבל הפנימיות ואז נקרא תמים.
It is only that the body must be refined so that it can receive the penimiyus, and then it is called tamim (whole).
A person becomes "whole" not by removing the body but by perfecting it into a fitting vessel that can hold its inner soul.
ולכן המילה מתקן הגוף להיות כלי מוכן לקבל הנשמה.
Therefore milah refines the body to be a vessel ready to receive the neshamah.
Removing the orlah turns the body into a prepared kli (vessel) capable of receiving the light of the soul.
ואיתא שבנ"י יש להם שתי אותות שבת ומילה.
It is taught that Bnei Yisrael have two signs (osos): Shabbos and milah.
Both Shabbos and the bris milah serve as a "sign" of the bond between Hashem and Bnei Yisrael.
ובחול תפילין ומילה.
And on weekdays: tefillin and milah.
On weekdays, when there is no Shabbos sign, tefillin together with milah serve as the signs of this bond.
כי התפילין הם ג"כ הארת הנשמה המאירה באדם בעת קיים המצוה כמ"ש ז"ל וראו כל עמי הארץ כו' שם ה' נקרא עליך זו תפילין שבראש.
For tefillin too are an illumination of the neshamah that shines in a person when he fulfills the mitzvah, as Chazal said on "and all the peoples of the earth shall see... that the Name of Hashem is called upon you" (Devarim 28:10) — this refers to the tefillin of the head.
Wearing tefillin draws down a revealed light of the soul, so that Hashem's Name visibly rests upon the Jew.
וכמו כן בשבת שיש נשמה יתירה כל היום.
And likewise on Shabbos, when there is a neshamah yeseirah (extra soul) the entire day.
On Shabbos the additional soul provides this illumination throughout the whole day, without need for tefillin.
וע"י המילה יכולין לקבל הארות האלה.
And through milah one is able to receive these illuminations.
It is the milah, which makes the body a fit vessel, that enables a person to absorb the lights of Shabbos and tefillin.
דאיתא אין כלי מחזיק ברכה אלא שלום.
For it is taught: there is no vessel that holds blessing except shalom (peace/wholeness).
Only a vessel that is whole and unified — at peace within itself — can contain berachah; a broken vessel cannot hold it.
ולכן על ידי המילה שנעשין תמים יכולין לקבל השבת.
Therefore through milah, by which one becomes tamim, one is able to receive Shabbos.
Since milah makes the body whole ("tamim," akin to "shalom"), it becomes the very vessel able to hold the blessing of Shabbos.
שהוא הברכה כמ"ש ויברך את יום השביעי.
For Shabbos is the blessing, as it is written "and He blessed the seventh day" (Bereishis 2:3).
Shabbos is itself the source of berachah, the blessing that the whole vessel of milah can now receive.
ובנ"י מקבלין בחי' השבת בתוכם ממש וע"ז אומרים בקידוש היום ושבת קדשו כו' הנחילנו.
And Bnei Yisrael receive the aspect of Shabbos literally within themselves, and concerning this we say in the Kiddush of the day "and His holy Shabbos... He gave us as an inheritance."
Shabbos is not merely an external day; its kedushah is absorbed inside the Jew himself, as the Kiddush expresses.
ואח"כ שנית ושבת קדשך כו' הנחלתנו.
And afterward, a second time: "and Your holy Shabbos... You gave us as an inheritance."
The Kiddush mentions the inheritance of Shabbos twice, and the Sefas Emes will explain why.
כי מקודם הברכה על כלל מצות השבת שניתן לנו.
For the first is the berachah over the general mitzvah of Shabbos that was given to us.
The first mention thanks Hashem for the gift of the mitzvah of Shabbos itself.
ואח"כ הוא על הארה שמקבלין בנפשותינו בכל שבת ושבת.
And afterward it is over the illumination that we receive in our souls every single Shabbos.
The second mention thanks Hashem for the personal light that enters each Jew's soul on every Shabbos.
הנחלתנו הוא שבני ישראל עצמם הם משתנים מימי המעשה ליום השבת כדאיתא אין דומה מאור פניו של אדם בשבת לחול.
"You gave us as an inheritance" means that Bnei Yisrael themselves are changed from the weekdays to the day of Shabbos, as it is taught: the radiance of a person's face on Shabbos is unlike that of a weekday.
The deeper inheritance is that the Jew himself is transformed on Shabbos — even his face shines differently than during the week.
וגם בכל המצות כן הוא שצריכין לקבל המצוה בנפשותינו כמ"ש חז"ל ועשיתם אותם עצמיכם כו'
And so it is with all the mitzvos — that we must receive the mitzvah within our souls, as Chazal expounded "and you shall do them" (va'asisem osam) as if it read "you shall make yourselves."
Every mitzvah is meant not only to be performed externally but to reshape the person himself from within.
ולכן ע"י המילה יכולים להיות כלים לקבל השבת.
Therefore through milah we are able to become vessels to receive Shabbos.
Milah, which perfects the body, is what enables a Jew to internalize the kedushah of Shabbos within himself.
וכ"כ ובמנוחתו לא ישכנו ערלים:
And so it is written (in the Shabbos prayers): "and in His rest the arelim (uncircumcised) shall not dwell."
Only those who have been refined through milah can enter into the rest and inner blessing of Shabbos; the "uncircumcised" — those lacking this refinement — cannot.
Summary: The body is the garment of the soul, and milah refines it into a whole vessel ("tamim") fit to receive holiness. Because only a whole, peaceful vessel can hold berachah, milah is what enables Bnei Yisrael to receive the lights of tefillin and especially of Shabbos — internalizing its kedushah so that the Jew himself is transformed.
Related Teachings
- Garments of skin and the inner lightTazria · תרס"א · Essay 2
- Hidden light revealed through milahVayeira · תרנ"א · Essay 1
- Milah as the opening to wholenessVayeira · תרל"ט · Essay 1
- The inner point as source of lifeVayeira · תרל"ד · Essay 1
- Milah and Shabbos uncover the hidden light in concealmentTazria · תרל"א · Essay 2
- Milah refines desire to reveal the inner pointLech Lecha · תרס"ה · Essay 2