Severity must yield to kindness and truth
Korach · Kohanim · Leviim · Chesed · Din · Machlokes
בענין מחלוקת קרח וגם מ"ש חז"ל בקהלם אל תחד כבודי כו' דידוע בחי' כהן ולוי ימינא ושמאלא כדאיתא בזוה"ק כי יש בתורה כל הדרכים שנק' תורת חסד ואש דת ותורת אמת.
Regarding the dispute of Korach, and also what Chazal said on "in their assembly let my honor not be united" (Bereishis 49:6) — for it is known that the aspects of Kohen and Levi are "right" and "left," as stated in the Zohar HaKadosh, for the Torah contains all the paths, being called "the Torah of chesed," "a fiery law (eish das)," and "the Torah of truth."
Torah encompasses all spiritual modes: kindness (the Kohen, the "right"), strict severity (the Levi, the "left," the "fiery law"), and a balancing truth. Korach's rebellion is rooted in a clash between these forces.
והלוים הם בחינות הדינין ואש לכן אמר יעקב אע"ה אחלקם ביעקב כו' שרצה שיבטלו כחם לכללות ישראל ושלא יוכלו להתקבץ כאחד בפני עצמם כי היו מכלים העולם בגודל אש הגבורה שבהם.
The Levi'im are the aspects of judgment and fire; therefore Yaakov Avinu, peace be upon him, said, "I will divide them in Yaakov" (Bereishis 49:7) — for he wished that their power be nullified into the totality of Klal Yisrael, and that they not be able to gather together as one on their own, for they would consume the world with the great fire of gevurah within them.
Levi's force is harsh, fiery din (judgment). Yaakov scattered Levi's descendants so their severity would be absorbed into the whole nation rather than concentrate and burn up the world with its intensity.
והנהגת הכלל לא יוכל להיות עפ"י דין רק בחסד.
And the governance of the collective cannot operate by strict din, but only by chesed.
A whole community can only be sustained through kindness; pure strict justice would destroy it.
והגם שנמצא יחידי סגולה שיכולין לעמוד במדה"ד.
And although there are select individuals who can withstand the standard of strict judgment (middas ha-din).
A rare few elite tzaddikim can survive being judged by exacting justice.
מ"מ צריכין לבטל מדתם לבחי' החסד.
Nevertheless, they must nullify their own attribute to the aspect of chesed.
Even these elite individuals are required to subordinate their capacity for severity to the way of kindness, for the sake of the community.
ובמדרש סוף במדבר אל תכריתו כו' שבט כו' הקהתי הה"ד עין ה' אל יראיו למיחלים לחסדו.
And in the Midrash at the end of Bamidbar: "Do not cut off... the tribe... of the Kehasi" (Bamidbar 4:18) — this is what is written, "The eye of Hashem is upon those who fear Him, upon those who hope for His chesed" (Tehillim 33:18).
The Midrash links the warning to protect the Kehasites with the verse about those who fear Hashem yet hope for His kindness — the very theme of tempering severity with chesed.
פי' כי היראים צריכין להיות מיחלים לחסדו שלא לחפוץ להנהיג במדה"ד.
The explanation is that the God-fearing must be among those who hope for His chesed, not desiring to govern by middas ha-din.
Those with deep yiras Shomayim must yearn specifically for Hashem's kindness and not wish to run the world by strict judgment.
הגם כי אין מחסור ליראיו כתיב.
Even though it is written, "there is no lack for those who fear Him" (Tehillim 34:10).
Although the God-fearing lack nothing and might seem able to stand on their own merit.
אבל בעוה"ז אין יכולין להתקיים במדה"ד ואותן יראי ה' המיחלים לחסדו בהם בוחר ה' ולכן צוה המקום ב"ה שיבטלו הלוים אל הכהנים.
But in this world one cannot endure under middas ha-din, and those who fear Hashem yet hope for His chesed — them Hashem chooses; therefore the Omnipresent, Blessed is He, commanded that the Levi'im be nullified to the Kohanim.
Since no one can survive pure judgment in this world, Hashem favors the God-fearing who still rely on kindness, and so He ordained that Levi (severity) be subordinate to the Kohen (chesed).
וכתי' אהרן ובניו יבואו כו'.
And it is written, "Aharon and his sons shall come..." (Bamidbar 4:5).
The Kohanim, Aharon's family, are given precedence in the service of the Mishkan.
כי בשעת המסעות נשאו הלוים כלי המשכן והארון.
For at the time of the journeys, the Levi'im carried the vessels of the Mishkan and the Aron.
When the camp traveled, it was the Levi'im who bore the holy vessels.
ובשעת החני' היו הכהנים משמשין מבפנים ולוים בחוץ דכתיב ויהי בנסוע כו' ויפוצו אויביך כו'.
But at the time of encampment, the Kohanim served within and the Levi'im outside, as it is written, "And it was, when the Aron traveled... Your enemies shall be scattered..." (Bamidbar 10:35).
Travel is a time of battle and scattering of enemies — the realm of the Levi'im's fierce energy — whereas at rest, the inner service belongs to the Kohanim of kindness.
כי הנסיעה הי' בחי' מלחמה עם הסט"א והלוים הם אנשי המלחמה בכלל ישראל.
For the journeying was the aspect of war with the sitra achra (the "other side"), and the Levi'im are the men of war within Klal Yisrael.
Movement through the wilderness represented spiritual combat against the forces of evil, and the Levi'im's fiery gevurah makes them the nation's warriors.
והכהנים בחי' המנוחה.
And the Kohanim are the aspect of rest/tranquility.
The Kohanim, by contrast, embody the peaceful, restful dimension of chesed.
והכינוס היא בבחי' החסד וסימנך ובהקהיל את הקהל תתקעו ולא תריעו כי התקיעה הוא בחי' החסד והרחמים והתרועה בדין ובחי' אהרן הכהן הוא תורת חסד.
And the gathering-in is in the aspect of chesed, and your sign is, "And when you assemble the congregation you shall blow a tekiah and not a teruah" (Bamidbar 10:7) — for the tekiah is the aspect of chesed and rachamim (mercy), while the teruah is of din; and the aspect of Aharon the Kohen is "the Torah of chesed."
Gathering the people calls for the long, steady tekiah-blast of mercy rather than the broken teruah of judgment, paralleling Aharon's role as the embodiment of kindness.
ולכן ניתן לו לברך את בנ"י מצות ברכת כהנים.
Therefore he was given the mitzvah of Birkas Kohanim, to bless Bnei Yisrael.
Because Aharon personifies chesed, it is fitting that the Kohanim are entrusted with blessing the people.
והלוים הם בחי' אש דת ולכן כתיב בפרשת תבוא וענו הלוים כו' קול רם כו' כל הארורים הכתובים שם.
And the Levi'im are the aspect of "fiery law," and therefore it is written in Parshas Ki Savo, "and the Levi'im shall declare... in a loud voice..." (Devarim 27:14) — all the curses written there.
Consistent with their dimension of din, the Levi'im are the ones who proclaim the curses at Har Gerizim and Har Eival.
והגם כי גם הכהנים היו שם מ"מ בקרא כתיב הלוים.
And although the Kohanim were also there, nevertheless the verse writes "the Levi'im."
Even though Kohanim participated, the Torah specifically names the Levi'im, because the curses belong to the side of severity.
ויתכן כי הכהנים היו מצד הברכות והלוים מצד הארורים.
And it is plausible that the Kohanim were on the side of the blessings and the Levi'im on the side of the curses.
The two groups divided according to their natures: Kohanim aligned with the blessings of chesed, Levi'im with the curses of din.
ובאמת לכל אחד יש חלק בתורה [כדאיתא בזוה"ק לוים בארונא אשלים כולא ע"ש והרמז דאיתא לא (התחיל התורה) [*נברא העולם] בא' משום שהוא לשון ארור.
And in truth each one has a portion in the Torah [as stated in the Zohar HaKadosh, that the Levi'im, through the Aron, completed everything — see there; and the hint is in the teaching that the world was not created with [the letter] alef because it is the language of "arur" (cursed).
Both Kohen and Levi have their share in Torah. Chazal note the world was not begun with alef (which starts "arur," cursed), hinting at the place of the "left side" of severity.
והתורה התחיל אנכי להודיע כי בקבלת התורה ניתקן גם שמאלא].
And the Torah [at Sinai] began with "Anochi" — to make known that through the receiving of the Torah, the "left" (the side of severity) too was rectified].
Though creation avoided alef, the Aseres HaDibros open with "Anochi" (which begins with alef), teaching that Kabbalas HaTorah rectifies even the harsh "left side."
אבל משה רבינו ע"ה הי' בחי' תורת אמת והוא הממוצע הכולל ב' הדרכים והיו צריכין קרח ועדתו לבטל כחם אליו כדאיתא בזוה"ק בראשית:
But Moshe Rabbeinu, peace be upon him, was the aspect of "the Torah of truth," the intermediary that includes both paths; and Korach and his assembly needed to nullify their power to him, as stated in the Zohar HaKadosh in Bereishis.
Moshe embodies the balancing "Torah of truth" that unites chesed and din. Korach's error was refusing to nullify himself to Moshe, the harmonizing center; had he done so, his "left-sided" force would have found its proper, rectified place.
Summary: The Torah contains three paths — chesed (the Kohen, "right"), the fiery din (the Levi, "left"), and the balancing "Torah of truth" (Moshe). Levi's intense severity must be subordinated to the Kohen's kindness, for the world and the community can endure only through chesed, not strict judgment. This is why Hashem subordinated the Levi'im to the Kohanim. Korach's rebellion was a failure to nullify his "left-sided" power to Moshe Rabbeinu, the unifying center who reconciles both forces.
Related Teachings
- Terumah, ma'aser, and chesed subduing dinKorach · תרנ"ו · Essay 2
- Aharon's daily Divine choosing versus KorachKorach · תרמ"ב · Essay 1
- Korach's flaw: self-made wholeness vs bittulKorach · תרמ"א · Essay 1
- Drawing close to Hashem by receiving His chesedVayeira · תרס"ה · Essay 2
- Aharon draws chesed over dinTetzaveh · תרס"ב · Essay 1
- Dual Paths of Good and EvilVayishlach · תרס"ב · Essay 3